|
101 Bright Ideas: ESL Activities
For All Ages by Claire Maria Ford

 |
101 Bright Ideas: ESL Activities For
All Ages does not have many activities
that would be beneficial to a student of English as a second
or foreign language hoping to improve her language skills. Far
too many of the suggestions deal only with letter or word games
requiring little or no communication. Perhaps one or two, such
as categorization or association, may be useful for vocabulary
building, but I felt that many others lacked any obvious pedagogical
purpose. Activities that could be classed as communicative were
a perplexing mixture of either boring and easy, or interesting
but too difficult without considerable language support from
the teacher. Some suggestions entailed bribing students with
fake money in order to get them to participate, a ruse that will
wear thin if the activity is not worthwhile. Others, based on
TV game shows, looked fun, but perhaps teachers will already
be familiar with most of these anyway.
Although I liked the organization and simple layout of the book,
some activities were also no more than simple layouts, such as
calendars or blank Valentine cards that students were expected
to complete. When language was presented, it was not always satisfactory.
For example, Who is the bald Irish female singer?, Where
do the pygmies live? and Who is the best basketball player
in the NBA? were suggestions, with answers, for a mega
quiz.
If you are an EFL or ESL teacher interested in developing your
students' communication skills or language proficiency, and want
them to engage in critical and purposeful language learning,
then I cannot recommend this book.
Read about 101
Bright Ideas: ESL Activities For All Ages at Amazon.com.
|